Method
How we rate nursing homes
Short version: we start with what state inspectors actually found, we keep serious problems visible, and no one can pay to change the order.
Why inspections come first
Medicare's overall star rating blends three things: health inspections, staffing, and quality measures. Quality measures are largely reported by the homes themselves. Inspections are done in person, unannounced, by state surveyors working for CMS. That's why we think the inspection record is the most trustworthy single signal.
The blend can hide a lot. In Miami-Dade, 28 of 54 homes are 5 stars overall, but only 8 are 5 stars on inspections (CMS data processed October 1, 2026).
The ranking, step by step
- Flags go last. Homes with a CMS abuse icon or Special Focus status (including candidates) are placed below every unflagged home, whatever their stars. We still list them and show why.
- Health inspection stars, highest first.
- CMS's weighted inspection score, lowest first. It weighs recent inspections more and counts how serious and widespread each problem was.
- Fewest serious citations in the last three years: actual harm (levels G–I) and immediate jeopardy (levels J–L).
- Then staffing stars, then overall stars, then fewer citations on the latest inspection, then the more recent inspection.
We don't re-score or change CMS's stars or numbers. Where an older serious citation is still in the 3-year file, we show it even if the current star rating looks fine.
What the severity letters mean
| Letters | Plain English |
|---|---|
| J, K, L | Immediate jeopardy. A situation that put residents at risk of serious injury, serious harm, or death. |
| G, H, I | Actual harm. A resident was harmed, but it wasn't immediate jeopardy. |
| D, E, F | Could cause harm. No one was found to be harmed, but the problem could cause more than minimal harm. Most citations are in this group. |
| A, B, C | Minor. Potential for only minimal harm. |
Within each group, the first letter means "isolated", the second "a pattern", and the third "widespread".
Where the data comes from
Everything comes from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Provider Data Catalog, the same data behind Medicare Care Compare: Provider Information, Health Deficiencies (last three years), Penalties, and State and US Averages. CMS refreshes it monthly, and we re-pull it when they do. Current data: processed by CMS on October 1, 2026.
Every home's page links to its official Care Compare record so you can check us.
Our review promise
We don't publish family reviews yet. When we do, they'll meet a higher standard than most review sites:
- Real families only. Every review will come from a family we've verified actually had a loved one at that home, for example with a confirmation and proof of a visit or admission.
- Never bought or made up. We never buy, write, edit for praise, or AI-generate reviews. Facilities can't pay to remove or hide them.
- Critical reviews too. We publish the hard reviews alongside the kind ones, and facilities can respond publicly.
- The record still comes first. Reviews never change our inspection-based ranking. They sit beside the official record, not on top of it.
Why this matters: many review sites don't check that a reviewer ever set foot in the home, so a page full of glowing stars can be written by anyone. Since 2024, a Federal Trade Commission rule bans fake reviews and paying for positive ones. That's the legal minimum. We go further by verifying every reviewer before anything is published.
Coming soon: verified family reviews. Want to share your experience? Get in touch or email hello@saidplain.com.
What this doesn't cover (yet)
- Assisted living and memory care. Florida licenses these separately, and they're not in the CMS files. We plan to add the state's inspection records later.
- The newest complaints. Complaint investigations can happen between CMS refreshes.
- How it feels inside. Numbers can't tell you about warmth, food, or language. Visit, ideally twice and once unannounced, and talk to residents' families.